Premium
Lavallette
Ocean County — Central Barnegat Peninsula
AVERAGE HOME PRICE
$1,441,424
MEDIAN LISTING PRICE
$1,720,000
AVG DAYS ON MARKET
45 – 90 days
EST ANNUAL STR INCOME
$55,000 — $75,000
About Lavallette
Lavallette is the crown jewel of the Barnegat Peninsula and its real estate market reflects that status completely. Sitting roughly in the middle of the barrier island, Lavallette has long been considered the most desirable residential address on the peninsula. The data consistently backs up that reputation.
What distinguishes Lavallette from every other town on this island is its intentional restraint. The borough has historically resisted overdevelopment and kept commercial activity to an absolute minimum. There is no boardwalk amusement park. No bar strip. No carnival rides. No chain restaurants. What there is is a quiet, exceptionally maintained barrier island town with a loyal year-round community of approximately 1,884 residents, pristine ocean and bay beaches, and Barnegat Bay sunsets that people drive two hours to see.
The average home price is $1,441,424 with a median listing price of $1.72 million. One hundred and forty-nine homes sold in the past twelve months. One bayfront property generated $65,000 in rental income in 2025 and was already at $50,000 for 2026 before summer had fully arrived.
The Lavallette Market Right Now
The Lavallette market is being reshaped by the same bungalow replacement wave that has transformed Ortley Beach. The original Shore bungalows that defined this town for generations are being purchased by developers and replaced with luxury coastal construction at price points starting at $1.3 million and extending well above $1.7 million. A recently completed bayfront home on Pershing Boulevard is listed above $1.6 million. Each new build resets the comparable base for every adjacent property.
The median listing price of $1.72 million and the average of $1.44 million reflect a market with a wide spread between older original stock and new construction. The oldest and most modest properties are being acquired for their lots more than their improvements. For owners of older homes in Lavallette who have been considering selling, the developer interest in this town is at its highest point in decades.
For buyers, the entry point is challenging but the fundamentals justify it. Lavallette has never experienced a prolonged price correction in modern memory. Its combination of scarcity, location, character preservation, and proximity to both the ocean and the bay creates demand that outpaces whatever supply is available.
Short-Term Rental Performance
PEAK SEASON WEEKLY RATE
$450 — $900
SHOULDER SEASON MONTHLY RATE
$250 — $500
PEAK OCCUPANCY RATE
85 — 95%
ESTIMATED ANNUAL INCOME
$55,000 — $75,000 (bayfront up to $90,000+)
STR REGULATION STATUS
Mixed
The STR market in Lavallette is strong because the town's character attracts a demographic of renter that pays well and treats properties with respect. The typical Lavallette renter is a family from New York or Philadelphia looking for a quiet, upscale Shore experience.
They pay $4,000 to $8,000 per peak week and they rebook. That tenant quality drives above-average rental income and below-average property wear. Lavallette has STR registration requirements — verify with the borough.
Flood Zone Information
PRIMARY FEMA ZONES
AE zone for most residential areas
ESTIMATED ANNUAL FLOOD INSURANCE
$3,000 — $7,000 depending on elevation
ELEVATION CERTIFICATE
Required for new construction, strongly recommended for all purchases
Lavallette sits on a narrow barrier island with ocean to the east and bay to the west, creating flood exposure on both sides under major storm conditions. Properties elevated above base flood elevation carry materially lower insurance costs.
Post-Sandy new construction in Lavallette is built to elevated standards. Older properties that have not been raised require careful insurance analysis before purchase. Budget $4,000 to $7,000 annually for flood insurance as a baseline carrying cost.
What We Are Watching in Lavallette
The character of Lavallette is being preserved by its residents and the borough government, but the pressure from luxury development is intensifying every year. The town that exists today — with its quiet streets, modest commercial footprint, and genuine community character — is slowly but measurably changing. Buyers who want the authentic Lavallette experience should act while it is still available at current prices.
Related coverage
Get weekly updates on Lavallette and the full Jersey Shore market.
Forever free. Unsubscribe anytime.
